904L

904L is a high-alloy austenitic stainless steel that Rolex made famous in watches. It was an established chemical-industry alloy before it was a watch case, and Rolex did not invent it. Compared with 316L it adds chromium, nickel, molybdenum and copper, which gives it better resistance to corrosion, at the cost of a higher raw price. Rolex began using it in the 1980s and has marketed it as Oystersteel since 2018.

A Rolex Submariner and GMT Master II in Oystersteel

Rolex Submariner and GMT Master II, both in 904L steel, trademarked as Oystersteel. Photo: Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0.

The recipe

Typical 904L composition is 19 to 23 percent chromium, 23 to 28 percent nickel, 4 to 5 percent molybdenum and 1 to 2 percent copper, with carbon capped at 0.020 percent. 316L has 16 to 18 percent chromium, 10 to 14 percent nickel and 2 to 3 percent molybdenum, and no copper. On the pitting resistance equivalent number (PREN), 904L scores about 34 to 36 against about 26 for 316L. The formula weights molybdenum by 3.3 and nitrogen by 16 per percent, so the extra molybdenum accounts for most of the difference. Copper does something else: it improves resistance in reducing acids such as sulfuric, which is what the alloy was designed for in chemical plants, and sits between standard 316L and Alloy 20 in the range of uses.

From chemical plants to wrists

Omega experimented with 904L in 1971 and 1972, inspired by the diving company Comex. Rolex began using it in the 1980s, first for the Sea-Dweller and later the Submariner, and one dealer dates this to 1985, replacing 316L. Rolex used it first for cases and then for bracelets. One source says Rolex moved all of its stainless-steel watches to 904L in 2003. In 2018 Rolex began calling the steel Oystersteel, introducing the branding at Baselworld. Rolex makes Oystersteel in-house at its Geneva foundry, which gives it control over quality.

What it does well

The polish is the visible difference: 904L takes a higher polish and looks shinier than 316L. Rolex states that Oystersteel resists saltwater and moisture better than 316L and holds a bright sheen that does not dull over time. A maker of 316L dive watches argues that in real watch use the corrosion advantage is narrower than marketing suggests.

A Rolex Submariner Professional dive watch

Rolex Submariner Professional, in Oystersteel. Photo: Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0.

Machining and hardness

Sources disagree on how hard 904L is to work. One says Rolex reportedly replaced much of its cutting machinery to work it, and that this may be why other premium brands have not adopted it widely. Another cites a materials supplier saying 904L can be machined with standard methods, with commenters saying it is slightly harder to cut and needs different cutting tips. An austenitic steel with this much nickel work-hardens quickly: the cutting itself hardens the surface ahead of the tool, so the tool must cut under the hardened layer, which calls for slower speeds, sharp tools and more coolant.

On hardness, one source lists 316L at Rockwell 95 and 904L at Rockwell 70 to 90, which makes 904L the softer of the two. Rolex describes Oystersteel as scratch-resistant, a claim that has not been independently verified.

Nickel

904L has roughly twice the nickel of 316L, around 23 to 28 percent against 10 to 14. 316L also contains nickel, and titanium is suggested for people with nickel allergies.

Sources

Thanks for reading this.

Recommended articles