Stainless Steel

Stainless steel is steel with enough chromium in it to protect itself. That one addition, at least 10.5 percent, changes iron from a metal that rusts into a metal that can sit against skin for decades, survive seawater and take a polish that lasts. It is the default case material for a reason: it is strong, easy to work, easy to finish, and cheaper than titanium, gold or ceramic. Almost every watch that is not trying to make a statement about weight, luxury or scratch resistance is made from it.

Four analog wristwatches with stainless steel cases and bracelets

Stainless steel in its natural habitat: everyday wristwatches. Photo: Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0.

How it works

The protection comes from chromium, not from a coating. Steel needs at least 10.5 percent chromium to count as stainless, and most watch cases contain 16 to 18 percent. That chromium reacts with oxygen in the air to form a thin, invisible layer of chromium oxide on the surface, and that layer blocks oxygen and water from reaching the iron underneath.

The layer is self-repairing. Scratch the surface and chromium from the steel underneath reacts with oxygen again, so the layer reforms in a few minutes, though it needs oxygen to do it. That is why stainless steel can stain in a closed, oxygen-starved environment, such as a damp watch case left in a drawer for months, or in the screw threads of a caseback that rarely opens.

The layer does not protect against everything. Chlorides from salt water, sweat or a swimming pool attack it and cause pitting, which is small, localised corrosion that digs into the metal. The alloying elements that matter here are molybdenum and nitrogen, and their effect is measured by a formula called the pitting resistance equivalent number, or PREN. The formula is chromium plus 3.3 times molybdenum plus 16 times nitrogen. For 316L, which contains 16 to 18 percent chromium and 2 to 3 percent molybdenum, the number is about 26. For 904L, which contains 19 to 21 percent chromium and 4 to 5 percent molybdenum, it is about 35.

Austenitic steel is the common form. It is non-magnetic in the annealed state and cannot be hardened by heat treatment, only by working. The steel of most watch cases is austenitic.

Carbon is a problem. Between roughly 450 and 850 degrees Celsius, as in welding, carbon combines with chromium to form carbides at the grain boundaries, and the metal next to them is left with too little chromium to stay stainless. This is sensitization. Keeping the carbon low, which is what the L in 316L means, avoids it.

A rifle-barrel experiment

Stainless steel came out of a search for something else. In 1912 a laboratory in Sheffield was commissioned to study erosion in rifle barrels, and the metallurgist Harry Brearley went looking for an erosion-resistant steel. On 13 August 1913 he made an alloy with 12.8 percent chromium and 0.24 percent carbon, and it resisted corrosion. R.F. Mosley & Co., a cutlery firm at Portland Works, produced test batches under his supervision.

Watch steels

The grade used in the vast majority of stainless watches is 316L, an austenitic steel alloyed mainly with chromium, nickel and molybdenum. Molybdenum, roughly 2 to 3 percent in the 316 series, improves resistance to pitting and crevice corrosion in salt water, and the grade resists both seawater and sweat. It takes brushed, polished and bead-blasted finishes, and it is widely available and economical.

An Omega Speedmaster chronograph in stainless steel

The Omega Speedmaster, a stainless steel icon. Steel cases take both polished and brushed finishes well. Photo: Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0.

Rolex began moving to 904L in the 1980s, first on the Sea-Dweller. 316L had developed pitting in the screw threads of dive watch case backs, which is a crevice and chloride problem. 904L has more nickel and molybdenum, and is more corrosion-resistant but softer and more expensive. Rolex now markets the alloy as Oystersteel, a name it began using in 2018, and other brands, including Omega and Seiko, also use 904L.

Some German makers go further. Sinn uses what it calls submarine steel, supplied by ThyssenKrupp, with a composition that has not been disclosed, and applies Tegiment, a low-temperature case-hardening process that diffuses carbon into the surface. Damasko’s ice-hardened steel uses a similar low-temperature process to harden the surface. Case hardening does not peel the way a coating can, but it will not resist large impacts.

Sources

Thanks for reading this.

Recommended articles