A watch that keeps time in winter but runs slow in summer is not broken. It is doing what steel does when it warms up. Temperature changes the stiffness of the balance spring, and the spring sets the rate. For most of watchmaking history, temperature was the largest single source of error, and the fight against it produced some of the most important inventions in horology.
Chronometers like this 1928 Movado earned the title by holding their rate across temperatures, not just positions. Photo: Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0.
Why heat slows a watch
A balance spring is a coil of metal. When it warms, two things happen. The metal expands, so the spring gets longer, and it gets less stiff, so it pushes back less hard. Both effects make the balance swing more slowly. The watch loses time.
When it cools, the opposite happens. The spring contracts and stiffens, the balance swings faster, and the watch gains time. The change is not small. An ordinary steel hairspring can change the rate by several seconds a day for every degree Celsius, enough to turn a good watch into a poor one between a cold morning and a warm afternoon.
The bimetallic balance
The first answer was to make the balance wheel compensate for the spring. A bimetallic balance has a rim made of two metals fused together, usually brass on the outside and steel on the inside. Brass expands more than steel when it warms, so the rim bends inward as the temperature rises. That moves mass closer to the center, which speeds the balance up and cancels the slowing of the spring.
When the temperature falls, the rim bends outward, mass moves away from the center, and the balance slows down to cancel the stiffening spring. The idea was developed by Pierre Le Roy in the 18th century and refined by John Arnold, Thomas Earnshaw, and others. It worked well enough to make marine chronometers practical, but it was not perfect.
The error in the middle
A bimetallic balance can be adjusted to be correct at two temperatures, usually the cold and hot extremes. Between those points, it is wrong. The spring’s stiffness does not change in a straight line with temperature, but the balance’s compensation does, so the two curves cross at the extremes and diverge in the middle. This is called the middle temperature error, and it could cost a watch several seconds a day at ordinary room temperature.
The error was known for a century before it was understood. Guillaume, who studied the problem in the 1890s, showed that the spring’s behavior was the cause, and that no mechanical balance could fully correct it. The solution had to be in the spring itself.
The balance wheel and hairspring, the two parts temperature acts on. Photo: Wikimedia Commons, public domain.
Guillaume’s alloys
Charles Edouard Guillaume, a Swiss physicist working at the International Bureau of Weights and Measures in Paris, found the answer in nickel-steel alloys. Invar, an alloy of about 36 percent nickel, barely expands with temperature at all. Elinvar, developed around 1919, goes further: its elasticity barely changes with temperature. A hairspring made of Elinvar keeps almost the same stiffness from cold to hot, so the watch keeps almost the same rate.
Guillaume won the Nobel Prize in Physics in 1920 for this work, the only Nobel Prize ever awarded for horology. Elinvar and its successors made the bimetallic balance unnecessary. A watch with an Elinvar hairspring and a plain, uncut balance wheel could hold its rate across temperatures without mechanical compensation.
Nivarox, Spron, and silicon
Elinvar was the ancestor of the hairspring alloys used today. Nivarox, developed by Reinhard Straumann in the 1930s, is a nickel-iron alloy with small additions of chromium, beryllium, and other metals. Its name comes from the German for “non-variable, non-oxidizing.” It is stable, non-magnetic, and resistant to corrosion, and it became the standard hairspring material for Swiss watchmaking. Most mechanical watches made since the 1950s have a Nivarox hairspring.
Seiko developed its own alloy, Spron, for Grand Seiko. Spron 610, introduced in 2009, is a cobalt-nickel alloy with high elasticity and resistance to shock and magnetism. It is made in-house by Seiko and used in Grand Seiko movements.
Silicon is the newest answer. A silicon hairspring is etched from a wafer, not drawn from wire, and its elasticity changes very little with temperature. It is also non-magnetic and light, which helps with shock resistance. Silicon hairsprings are used by Patek Philippe, Breguet, Omega, and others, and they have largely solved the temperature problem that occupied watchmakers for two centuries.
What the tests ask
COSC tests movements at three temperatures, 8, 23, and 38 degrees Celsius, over 15 days. The thermal variation, the change in rate per degree, must stay within plus or minus 0.60 seconds per day per degree Celsius. A movement that passes has shown it can hold its rate from a cold morning to a hot afternoon, which is what the original chronometer trials were testing for.
Sources
- “The Remarkable History of the Guillaume Balance,” Phillips
- “Insight: Hairspring Materials and Evolution Part I,” SJX
- “Insight: Hairspring Materials and Evolution Part II,” SJX
- “A Revolution in Watchmaking: Silicon Balance Springs,” Ulysse Nardin
- “How the COSC Tests a Movement,” Caliber Corner
Thanks for reading this.

