Isochronism

Isochronism is the ability of an oscillator to keep the same period whether its swing is wide or narrow. A mainspring delivers less force as it unwinds, so the balance’s amplitude falls through the day, and a movement that is not isochronous changes its rate with its state of wind. The history of the hairspring, the regulator and the barrel is largely the history of keeping that change small.

A Breguet overcoil hairspring with its raised terminal curve

A Breguet overcoil hairspring, with its raised terminal curve designed to improve isochronism. Photo: Wikimedia Commons, public domain.

Why a spring is isochronous

A balance spring is isochronous when its restoring force is proportional to its displacement, so the period depends only on the spring’s stiffness and the balance’s inertia, not on how far it swings. In an ideal spring that holds at any amplitude, and a watch would keep the same rate from full wind to empty. Real springs depart from that ideal as they breathe, because the spring’s center of mass moves and the coils do not expand symmetrically.

The departure is larger at large amplitudes, where the spring’s geometry changes most, and at small amplitudes, where friction and the escapement’s influence are proportionally larger. Time Transformed notes that isochronism is therefore not a single property but a curve: the rate varies with amplitude, and the goal is to keep that curve flat over the amplitudes the watch actually uses.

Where isochronism is lost

Three places matter most. The first is the hairspring’s terminal curve, which determines how the spring breathes. A flat spiral expands off center, shifting the balance’s center of mass and changing the period with amplitude. The second is the regulator, whose pins can disturb the spring if they are not parallel or if the spring touches them unevenly. The third is the barrel, whose torque curve sets the amplitude range the watch must cover.

Silicon springs help, because they can be made with a geometry that is closer to ideal and because they are less affected by magnetism and temperature. They do not solve the problem by themselves, and a silicon spring in a poorly adjusted movement will still show isochronism error, but they reduce one source of variation.

The problem starts at the barrel

A mainspring delivers high torque when fully wound, settles at a median value for most of its running time and then drops sharply as it approaches the end of its reserve. SJX’s article on barrels describes that curve and notes that a watch’s amplitude follows it: high at full wind, steady in the middle, low at the end. If the oscillator is not isochronous, the rate follows the amplitude, and the watch gains or loses as the reserve falls.

The same article describes how makers soften that curve. Barrels in series unwind one after the other, so the torque stays steadier, and some movements use a remontoire or a constant-force device to isolate the escapement from the barrel’s variation. Those are expensive solutions, and most watches rely on the hairspring to absorb the barrel’s variation instead.

What the hairspring contributes

The flat balance spring was invented by Huygens in 1675, and Breguet’s own site says it had “a degree of isochronism” but was limited by its off-center breathing. In 1795 Abraham-Louis Breguet developed the overcoil, raising the spring’s last coil and reducing its lateral shift as it breathes. SJX’s overcoil article traces the idea from Breguet through Phillips, whose terminal curve is still used in high-grade movements, and notes that the overcoil’s benefit is greatest at large amplitudes, where the flat spiral’s error is largest.

SJX also notes modern developments: Breguet’s Souscription uses a non-magnetic Nivachron alloy hairspring with a Phillips terminal curve, and other makers use silicon springs with a similar overcoil shape. The principle has not changed since 1795, but the materials and the manufacturing precision have improved, so modern overcoils are closer to the ideal curve than Breguet’s hand-made originals.

Diagram of balance spring types: flat spiral, Breguet overcoil, and chronometer helix

Flat spiral versus Breguet overcoil and chronometer helix terminal shapes. Photo: Wikimedia Commons, public domain.

Free-sprung against regulated

A regulated balance has essentially fixed inertia, and the hairspring’s active length varies. An index, or regulator, moves curb pins along the spring, shortening or lengthening its active part to change the rate. The method is simple and cheap, but the pins can disturb the spring’s breathing, especially if they are not parallel or if the spring is not centered between them.

A free-sprung balance leaves the hairspring completely free. Rate is adjusted by moving small screws or weights on the balance rim, which changes its inertia without touching the spring. The method is more expensive and needs more skill to adjust, but it preserves the spring’s geometry and therefore its isochronism. WatchProSite’s comparison notes that both approaches can reach top timekeeping performance, but free-sprung balances are generally preferred for high-grade movements because they avoid the regulator’s disturbance.

Insight Luxury’s free-sprung article adds a practical point: a free-sprung balance is harder to regulate in the field, because it needs a timegrapher and a steady hand to move the screws, while a regulated balance can be adjusted with a simple tool. That trade-off explains why regulated balances remain common in mid-range watches, even though free-sprung balances are technically superior for isochronism.

Sources

Thanks for reading this.

Recommended articles