Silver was once the ordinary precious case metal. It was widely used in pocket watches and in the first wristwatches, then it faded during the 20th century as stainless steel took over. The reasons are chemical: silver is soft and it tarnishes. A few makers have brought it back in recent years, using tarnish-resistant alloys or treating the discoloration as patina.
A Waltham pocket watch, circa 1879, with a coin silver hunter case. For decades, this was the standard respectable watch. Photo: Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 2.0
How it works
Silver does not oxidize in air the way copper does. Its tarnish comes from sulfur: hydrogen sulfide and other sulfur compounds in the air react with the surface, and in the presence of oxygen form silver sulfide, a black film. The film thickens from a faint yellow through brown to black as it grows, and interference of light in the thin film gives the intermediate colors. Skin, wool, rubber and polluted air all carry sulfur, which is why a worn silver case darkens in patches.
Pure silver (999) is very soft and easy to deform, so it is rarely used for cases. Sterling silver, 925, is 92.5 percent silver alloyed with 7.5 percent copper for strength, and it has historically been used for cases and dials. The copper makes it harder and also makes it tarnish faster. Silver’s hardness is roughly 25 to 100 HV and its density about 10.5 g/cm³, and its main drawbacks are tarnishing, low hardness and weaker mechanical properties.
Silver as the everyday case
About a century ago, as pocket watches were becoming wristwatches, silver was the standard case material for inexpensive watches. Silver was common in pocket watches and early wristwatches. Swiss trench-style wristwatches from around 1917, with their hinged-back half-hunter cases, were often made in .935 silver, a grade a collector describes as better than sterling. Stainless steel is strong, rust-proof and easier to work, and it replaced silver through the 20th century. Silver cases survived mainly in niche, artisanal or heritage pieces.
A WWI-era trench watch. Many early wristwatches were silver-cased, right up until steel took over. Photo: Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0
A small return
Recent silver watches take different approaches to the old problems. Zenith’s Pilot Type 20 Extra Special Silver of 2019 is a 45 mm case in sterling silver, limited to 250 pieces at US$7,700. Unlike many sterling cases it is not plated with rhodium or gold, so it tarnishes in air, and the aging is presented as part of the appeal.
Tudor’s Black Bay Fifty-Eight 925, launched in 2021, is a 39 mm sterling silver diver. Tudor says its silver resists tarnishing without naming the other metals in the alloy. A reviewer who bought one pre-owned saw little tarnish, and light discoloration came off with a damp microfiber cloth. Sinn’s 1739 Ag B uses a 39 mm case in 935 Argentium silver, and James Lamb’s Origin Series uses handmade 935 Argentium cases. Argentium replaces some of the copper with germanium, which forms a protective oxide layer and slows the sulfur reaction.
Sources
- “Silver,” Horopedia
- “Introducing the Zenith Pilot Type 20 Extra Special Silver,” SJX
- “Best Silver Watches,” Time+Tide
- “A Week on the Wrist with the Tudor Black Bay 58 925,” T3
- “c. 1917 935 Silver Trench Watch,” Collectors Weekly
Thanks for reading this.

