Forging

Forging shapes solid metal by pressing it between dies, and in watchmaking it is a way to make a strong, dense case blank before machining. The through-line is grain: a forged part has its internal structure aligned to its shape, which is where the process gets its strength. The same pressing is also what limits it, because a forging is always a rough blank that the milling machine has to finish.

Red-hot metal being hammered on an anvil

Red-hot metal being hammered on an anvil, the oldest form of forging. Photo: Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0.

How it works

A billet is pressed into a die under heavy pressure. The metal is plastically deformed: its crystals, which are the grains of the metal, are stretched in the direction of flow, and the flow lines follow the contour of the die. Inclusions and weak boundaries line up along the flow, so the part is strongest in directions along the flow lines and the direction of loading can be chosen to suit them. A machined part cut from bar has flow lines that run straight through and end at the cut surface, so a crack can start at an exposed end; a forging has lines that run around the shape.

The pressure closes internal voids, as a billet is squeezed from all sides. Forging can be hot, when the billet is heated so the metal flows easily and recrystallizes into fine new grains as it deforms, or cold, when it is pressed at room temperature, which needs more force but gives a better surface and work-hardens the metal.

A case starts as a rough blank, either stamped from strip metal or forged from a solid billet, either heated (hot forging) or left at ambient temperature (cold forging) and pressed into a die. Forging is used for more complex or robust case designs, while stamping suits simpler shapes at high volume.

Why grain matters

Forging aligns the grain structure of the metal with the part’s shape, which improves strength, fatigue resistance and density, and this matters most for titanium and advanced stainless steels. A comparison of forged and cast parts makes the contrast with casting. Forging reshapes solid metal by compressive force to align and refine its grain structure, and the process closes voids, while casting can leave gas or shrinkage porosity, inclusions and other defects. Forged parts generally outperform cast ones in tensile, yield, impact and fatigue strength, with cited figures of about 26 percent higher tensile strength and about 37 percent higher fatigue strength.

Cold forging at Grand Seiko

A visit to Seiko’s Shiojiri factory describes cold forging of the case bodies of Grand Seiko and Credor watches, reserved for top-of-the-line models such as the SBGD001. The press makes two passes, the first at 30 tons and the second at 90 tons, and the metal is forged to the shape of the mold. The process aligns the grain structure of the metal, which makes the case very strong. Case finishing follows on the same shop floor, including zaratsu polishing, buffing and graining.

A large industrial forging press, circa 1900

An industrial forging press, circa 1900, doing at large scale what watch case forging does at small scale. Photo: Wikimedia Commons, public domain.

What forging cannot do

Forging produces a blank, and nearly all case machining that follows uses multi-axis CNC milling, with features such as lugs, the bezel and caseback apertures, the crown tube hole, the internal cavity and the gasket grooves cut afterward. Forging’s tooling cost makes it competitive as volume rises: in one indicative index, closed-die forging costs more than sand casting at 100 units but less at 10,000. Casting, by comparison, suits intricate geometries and internal passages that are costly to machine from forgings.

Sources

Thanks for reading this.

Recommended articles