Equation of Time

The equation of time is the difference between the time shown by the sun’s position and the time shown by a clock. Mechanical clocks run on mean time, an average of the solar day, and the complication displays how far the real sun has drifted from that average on a given day. The through-line is the cam: a single part that turns once a year and encodes the whole discrepancy, in clocks from the seventeenth century and in the wristwatches that still carry it.

Jaeger-LeCoultre Reverso

A Jaeger-LeCoultre Reverso. The line’s Grande Complication à Triptyque carried an equation of time among its 18 complications. Photo: Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0.

How it works

The solar day is unequal for two reasons. The larger is the tilt of the earth’s axis to its orbit, about 23.4 degrees. The sun moves along the ecliptic at a nearly constant rate, but a clock follows the celestial equator, and equal steps along the ecliptic are unequal when projected onto the equator. Near the solstices the projection is stretched, near the equinoxes compressed. This produces a term with a period of half a year and an amplitude of about 9.9 minutes.

The smaller reason is the eccentricity of the earth’s orbit, 0.0167. The earth moves faster near perihelion, in early January, and slower near aphelion, in early July, while its rotation is constant. This produces a term with a period of one year and an amplitude of about 7.7 minutes.

The two terms add to a curve that is well approximated by E = 9.87 sin 2B – 7.53 cos B – 1.5 sin B minutes, where B = 360 (N – 81) / 365 degrees and N is the day of the year. The result has two maxima and two minima: in 2020 the deepest minimum was about minus 14.24 minutes on 11 February and the highest maximum about 16.49 minutes on 2 November, with the two clocks agreeing on four days, 15 April, 12 June, 1 September and 24 December. A sundial is ahead of the clock when the value is positive.

A mechanism needs to reproduce this curve. A shaft turns once a year, from the calendar or the date wheel, and carries a cam cut to the shape of the curve. A feeler rests on the cam and its lever turns the movement of the cam into an angle. Plotted as a radius against date, the curve is an irregular kidney shape, the equation kidney.

There are two ways to read it. In the simple form, a subsidiary dial with a hand reads the difference from about minus 16 to plus 14 minutes, and the wearer does the sum. In the running form, called the équation marchante, a solar minute hand sits on a shaft concentric with the mean minute hand and is advanced or retarded by the cam, so the dial reads true solar time directly. The cam is cut for a fixed year, so the reading is exact only on one day of the leap cycle and drifts by a few seconds in the others, because the true curve shifts slightly with the leap year.

History as a chain of problems

Until the mid-seventeenth century clocks were not accurate enough for the difference to matter. Pendulums, better escapements and balance springs made accurate measurement possible, and printed equation tables followed, often sold with longcase clocks. Equation clocks then displayed true and mean time without calculation. Christiaan Huygens devised an equation kidney by 1695, though the Leiden clock that featured it is lost. Thomas Tompion made an equation clock for King William III in 1695. Joseph Williamson’s claim to the invention was recorded in the Philosophical Transactions in 1719, and his clock used a cam to adjust the length of the pendulum. John Ellicott and Thomas Mudge made an astronomical stop-watch with an equation of time around 1742, and Ferdinand Berthoud made a centre-seconds pocket watch with a running equation between about 1756 and 1762. Geneva adopted mean time around 1780, England in 1792 and Berlin in 1810.

Abraham-Louis Breguet’s earliest known attempt to show the equation of time in a portable watch is No. 444, completed in 1779 and sold in 1799. A pivoted auxiliary hand on the mean time hand shows the correction on a scale divided into five-minute intervals. The Marie-Antoinette, No. 160, was ordered around 1783 and carried every complication known. Breguet died in 1823 and his son Antoine-Louis finished the watch in 1827. Its equation of time is a subsidiary display driven by a cam and lever system, alongside a minute repeater, a perpetual calendar, a power-reserve indicator and a metallic thermometer.

Analemma traced on a sundial

An analemma traced on a sundial: the figure-eight path the sun’s position makes through the year, which is what the equation of time measures. Photo: Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0.

Where it stands now

George Daniels, in The Art of Breguet in 1975, wrote that indicating true solar time with a mean-time clock is simple in principle, requiring a cam that revolves once a year. The Breguet Marine Équation Marchante 5887 uses the solar minute hand method, with the cam on top of the tourbillon carriage, on a sapphire disc engraved with the months. Greubel Forsey’s Quantième Perpétuel à Équation of 2014 shows the equation of time on the reverse via two sapphire discs, one with a minute scale and one with red and blue sinusoidal sections that turn once a year, red for a positive difference and blue for a negative one. Only five were to be made.

Other makers have kept the equation in production. Ulysse Nardin’s equation displays use a cam and feeler system derived from the same principle, and Vacheron Constantin’s equation watches pair the complication with a perpetual calendar. The equation of time remains a niche complication, because it is a correction rather than a display in its own right, and because the cam must be cut for a specific year. It survives where makers want to show the full chain from the sun to the dial, in watches that are already carrying a perpetual calendar and a repeater.

The equation of time is not a way of telling the time. It is a way of showing why two ways of telling the time disagree, and by how much, on a given day. The cam is the whole complication in one part: a curve cut in metal, turned once a year, that carries the difference between the sun and the clock.

Sources

Thanks for reading this.